Jane Eyre

Friday, June 13, 2014

Jane Eyre
by Charlotte Bronte
★★★★★
 
There are books that resonate with you no matter what stage of life you are in. I first read Jane Eyre in 2007 when I was fresh out of college and in my first real job. Now, seven years later, I’ve had multiple “real” jobs, I’m married and I just celebrated my 30th birthday. I’m at a very different point in life, but the book is more relevant than ever. Rereading it gave me the chance to notice new aspects of the story and to deepen my love for the book in so many ways.
 
Jane Eyre is famous for its scenes with the stormy Mr. Rochester and his terrible secret, but really the book is not just a romance. At its heart it's about a woman who has been through so much. She’s lost everyone she loved and she’s been persecuted by the people who are supposed to care for her. Instead of being cowed into submission and settling into a lonely life of servitude, she stands up for herself. She never allows people to treat her badly. When there’s an easy way out and all she would have to do is compromise her beliefs she refuses to do it. She is strong and brave, but she doesn’t have to shout to get her point across. She has a quiet steely strength and determination that is incredibly rare.
When she unexpectedly falls in love, she never questions her feelings or tells herself she’s not worthy of loving someone in a higher station than she is. She also refuses to let him talk her into doing anything that she doesn’t want to do. No matter how much she loves him she won’t to do something that would make her lose her self-respect.
 
There are so many things I love about her as a character. She's grounded and doesn't let herself be swept away by emotion. She doesn't rely too heavily on what other people think of her. She won't settle for less than what she truly deserves. She works hard to get an education and then put it to use. She wants to be with someone who challenges her, instead of with someone who is comfortable and easy. She doesn’t fall for Rochester’s looks; it’s his personality and fire that win her.
 
I love that Jane knows what she wants but she rarely shows anyone else her true feelings. She is just incredibly brave. She leaves her teaching job, a reliable position, to venture out into something completely unknown in order to experience more of the world. Quitting your job in the 21st century is scary and we have networking and online job search sites. Imagine doing it in the 19th century when you don’t know a soul who can help you find a job.
 
**SPOILERS**
I love that Jane has a chance to return to her first home when her aunt is dying, because it gives her a chance to see how she’s changed since her time away. She has fallen in love not only with Mr. Rochester but also with Thornfield and with the freedom she has there.
 
The scene where Bertha tries on the veil gives me serious chills every time I read it. I know that her whole role in the story is controversial. Does that relationship make Rochester a villain? Was she truly mad or just a victim of circumstance? All great questions and they add an extra layer of depth to the story for me.
 
I also think that the nauseating proposal from St. John is crucial to the story. It shows us that Jane is not willing to settle for a loveless marriage, no matter how convenient. It’s much harder to turn something like that down when you have limited options, but she knows how unhappy it would make both of them.
**SPOILERS OVER**
 
BOTTOM LINE: One of my absolute favorite books, this classic will teach you something new about yourself each time you read it.
 
“I do not think, sir, you have any right to command me, merely because you are older than I, or because you have seen more of the world than I have; your claim to superiority depends on the use you have made of your time and experience.”
“I have for the first time found what I can truly love–I have found you. You are my sympathy–my better self–my good angel–I am bound to you with a strong attachment. I think you good, gifted, lovely: a fervent, a solemn passion is conceived in my heart; it leans to you, draws you to my centre and spring of life, wrap my existence about you–and, kindling in pure, powerful flame, fuses you and me in one.”
"I am no bird; and no net ensnares me; I am a free human being, with an independent will; which I now exert to leave you.”
 
Funny Side Notes:
- There are multiple times when Mr. Rochester calls her Janet. I checked different editions to see if it was just a typo but it's Janet and every edition that I have. I never noticed that before.
 
- There’s a line that says “It was the 5th of November, and a holiday.” This made me double check the dates online, but she was referring to Guy Fawkes Day! I had no idea that Guy Fawkes had been tried and executed all the way back in 1605. For some reason I thought it must have been later.
 
- Also, there’s a character named John Green who pops up in chapter 26. How funny is that? Another minor character that I had forgotten is Mr. Oliver, obviously my subconscious remembered that when we named our dog Oliver.
 
Check out the Crash Course episode about this book if you haven’t already seen it!

21 comments:

Sandy Nawrot said...

I have never read this book, which is a damned shame. I think I may even have it on my Kindle. One of these days, I swear I need to read it. I was the same way with Pride & Prejudice, and afterwards I could have just smacked myself for waiting so long.

JoAnn said...

It's definitely time for me to reread Jane Eyre. Love the cover shown here!

Sophia said...

I love Jane Eyre - she's one of my favorite strong women in literature, and someone all women can strive to emulate.

As a side note: I also noticed the Janet thing. I assumed it was just his pet name for her, since it's just Jane with an ending "t."

abibliophilesstyle said...

Janet is a diminutive form of Jane (a nickname) according to Behind the Name:
http://www.behindthename.com/name/janet

I have mixed feeling about this book. I love Jane as a heroine, but Mr. Rochester is a jerk. He treats Jane really badly - he's so rude at first, then he tries to make her jealous with Blanche, and he lies to her about everything! Jane is WAY too good for him.

Melissa (Avid Reader) said...

Sandy - It should definitely be on your MUST list!

JoAnn - I love that cover too! I've never seen it, but I have a bad habit of collecting vintage editions of this book.
Sophia - I agree, I just love her.

abibliophilesstyle - Interseting, I didn't know that. I know a lot of people hate Rochester. There are times when I do, but in the end I think I love the fact that Jane sees him for who he is and calls him out on it. She falls for him, but she never lets him get away with treating her badly.

bookertalk.com said...

Couldn't agree more with your comment that this book has much more to it than a romance. There's such a strong theme about the role of women and the limitations on their choices plus the complex situation of governesses.

Ruth said...

Great review. Agree that each time you reread [it], it will teach you something new about yourself.

Beautiful cover.

misfortuneofknowing said...

I LOVE Jane Eyre! Like you, I've been able to connect with this novel at different points in my life. Right now, I can't remember the specifics of St. John's proposal, but I do remember thinking that even Rochester's proposal is kind of awful (as passionate as it is!): “You strange, you almost unearthly thing!"

abibliophilesstyle said...

Don't get me wrong, I think Mr. Rochester is a great character, I just don't think he's a great person. He's interesting in a book, but I wouldn't want my daughter / sister / friend to fall for someone who treated her that way.

cleopatra said...

Everything you said is so true! It's just a wonderful book. I think it's been at least five years since I last read it, so I think that it's almost time for a re-read.

Great review!

Laura said...

I love books that you get something new out of each time you read them! Jane Eyre is definitely one of those for me, and I just love how you can think one thing about it, reread it and realise that you actually think something different, not because the book has changed, but because you have. It's awesome.

Marsar said...

Great review! It's true this is a book that resonates with you, and stays with you, no matter what! Jane's depth and strength as a heroine are unsurpassable.

a reader said...

Last time I read this one, I was wondering what was up with "Janet" too. I wonder if it's a nickname for Jane? Weird, since Jane is shorter!

raisedareader said...

I've read this book so many times, but reading your post, I can't help but think that I'll be rereading it by the end of the night. Everything about that books begs me to grab a cup of tea and a fluffy pillow and just will away the hours.

Erin @ www.raisedreading.wordpress.com

(Diane) Bibliophile By the Sea said...

Great review Melissa. I need to reconnect with Jane:)

o said...

I love this book too :) Looking forward to a re-read in the near future!

Great review :)

Andi said...

I love all the parts you mentioned here. This book!

Amy said...

I also read this book for the first time in 2007, right after graduating from college. Fun coincidence!

I actually love that Mr. Rochester calls her Janet. I've listened to part of the book on audio, and it sounds like such a cute pet name when it's spoken.

Melissa (Avid Reader) said...

bookertalk.com - Yes, and I loved that it's written so honestly by a woman during that time period. I'm sure the author's thoughts made their way out of Jane's mouth a few times.

Ruth - I love that cover too!

misfortuneofknowing - I know! Rochester stumbles over everything he's trying to say and ends up getting frustrated. I love that so much more than St. John's clinical approach.

abibliophilesstyle - I agree with that. I wouldn't want anyone I know dating him either, so many red flags!

cleopatra - I think every 5 years is the perfect time period for a re-read.

Laura - And every time you return to a favorite book you are deepening your relationship with the story!

Marsar - She really does have incredible strength of character.

a reader - Apparently it's a nickname for Jane, who knew?

raisedareader - Exactly! I put off re-reading it so it could be a treat during my birthday month. Now I think I'll need to make it a regular occurance.

Diane - It's such a treat to re-read it!

o - It definitely stands up for a re-read!

Amy - That's too funny!

Jeanne said...

I love this book, not least because it made possible Jasper Fforde's The Eyre Affair.

Melissa (Avid Reader) said...

Jeanne - Yes, yes, yes!!! I love that series so much.