Emma

Monday, August 17, 2015


I love participating in Austen in August each year. Jane Austen is one of my favorite authors and I never tire of returning to her work. This year I reread Emma.

Emma
by Jane Austen
★★★★☆

When I read through Austen’s main six novels, this one was the last one I read. It was 2006 and after reading Persuasion and Pride & Prejudice, Emma did not become my new favorite. Rereading it, as always, has given me a greater appreciation for the book and for what Austen was able to do with the character.
Oh Emma, you are so self-involved and sure of yourself. I loved this one so much more the second time around. The first time I just had such a hard time liking Emma. That’s not a bad thing; in fact in this case it means there is a lot more room for the character to evolve.

Emma is treated like the mature woman of the house because her older sister is married and her mother past away. But in so many ways Emma is still a young, immature girl. She thinks she’s always right and that her pleasure is the most important factor in most situations. So many of her decisions and matchmaking choices are based on what she wants and who she wants her friends to marry. She was raised in environment where she always got what she wanted and that selfishness continues to permeate in her 20s.

I adore the fact that Mr. Knightley is the only one who will call Emma on her BS. While everyone else is fawning over her he is challenging her to be a better person and think about her actions and influence on others. In my opinion, that’s the kind of partner every person needs. Mr. Knightley isn’t charming or entertaining, but he is the best kind of man. He lets his actions speak for themselves and is always looking out for the people around him. I’ve noticed that in Austen’s novels she has a lot more respect for men like this (Darcy, Knightley, Ferrars) than she does for those that immediately charm (Willoughby, Wickham, Crawford).

Speaking of the charmers, Frank Churchill is such a jerk. As I reread the book, knowing how it was going to end, I was so frustrated by his behavior. The way he manipulate situations and takes advantage of people’s good nature is horrible. I also thought it was interesting that Mr. Elton is often shown as the villain or at least someone you don't end up liking, but he really didn’t do anything wrong. He’s not a character I particularly like and his choice of a spouse is abominable, but I think most men would've thought Emma was interested in them based on her actions.

BOTTOM LINE: It’s Austen, so it’s delightful. I definitely have a great appreciation for this book now and I loved Knightley even more this time around. I think that Austen did a wonderful job showing character growth in this novel, second only to Anne’s in Persuasion.

“One half of the world cannot understand the pleasures of the other.”


“I may have lost my heart, but not my self-control. ”

“I cannot make speeches, Emma...If I loved you less, I might be able to talk about it more. But you know what I am. You hear nothing but truth from me. I have blamed you, and lectured you, and you have borne it as no other woman in England would have borne it.”
 

I think of all the Austen novels, Emma has led to some of the greatest film versions. Clueless is just amazing, Emma Approved actually made me appreciate the novel even more, and the 2009 miniseries was just beautifully done.

5 comments:

ebookclassics said...

Your review perfectly describes all of things I love and appreciate about Emma. I always understood why Emma is disliked, but always viewed her actions as forgivable because she always had good intentions. Knightley has always been my favourite Austen love interest because he's so patient and kind when dealing with Emma. Which Austen novel is your favourite?

Melissa (Avid Reader) said...

ebookclassics - Persuasion is my personal favorite. I love Anne's character and how their romance develops over time. But each time I read one of Austen's novels I fall even more in love with it!

Jillian said...

I love your thoughts on this one. I've only read it once & saw it as a tragedy -- Emma is rallied into her role as timid wife like the shrew in Shakespeare. Which might not at all be the point! (Or it might! Or maybe it's both, depending on the reader.) I hope to reread & experience some of the Austen magic, when a first look at Austen finds its complete opposite in a reread. :)

Brona Joy said...

Yes!
I noticed how unpleasant Frank was with this reread too. I felt extremely sorry for Jane Fairfax by the end - she was going to have to work hard all her life to keep Frank responsible, ethical and thoughtful.

But Mr Knightley just improves with each read *sigh!

Melissa (Avid Reader) said...

Brona - I felt bad for Jane as well. She gets the guy... but at that point would you really want him?